EchoStar Corporation
BHG Flagged an Apparent $15 Billion Gap Between DISH’s Reported Equity and Its Merger Value; EchoStar Later Recorded a $16.48 Billion Impairment
In late 2023, The Buxton Helmsley Group, Inc. (“BHG”) concluded that DISH Network Corporation’s financial statements overstated the value of its assets, chiefly the FCC licenses that made up most of its balance sheet, and that the overstatement was being carried into EchoStar Corporation’s pending acquisition of DISH. In BHG’s analysis, DISH had failed to record impairment required under ASC 350 and ASC 360, in violation of GAAP and Regulation S-X, and was in fact net-asset insolvent.
DISH reported about $53.7 billion of total assets, more than 71% of them intangible, and more than $18.4 billion of equity. By BHG’s calculation, the merger terms valued DISH’s equity at roughly $3 billion. BHG regarded the difference of more than $15 billion as an impairment that the two companies had effectively conceded in setting the price but had never recorded.
BHG pointed to the market for further evidence. Standard & Poor’s had assigned recovery ratings of 0% to major DISH senior unsecured note issues and 80% to most of its secured debt. DISH’s 2.375% notes due March 15, 2024, were yielding close to 33% by February 2024, and DISH stock traded about 85% below its reported book value. On its third-quarter 2023 earnings call, management described a “narrow path” to financial stability. BHG treated each of these as a triggering event under ASC 350 and ASC 360, along with the Federal Reserve’s rate increases and repeated credit downgrades. DISH had nonetheless recorded no impairment beyond scheduled amortization since the first quarter of 2020.
BHG also raised a conflict of interest. Charles Ergen was Chairman of both companies and controlled the voting power of each. In BHG’s view, EchoStar’s shareholders would have done better buying DISH’s assets in a Section 363 bankruptcy sale than paying for DISH’s equity and taking on its debt. That route, however, would have put Mr. Ergen’s control of DISH at risk.
The Approach
BHG wrote privately to DISH’s board on December 27, 2023, with copies to EchoStar’s board, Chief Executive Officer, Chief Accounting Officer, and Chief Legal Officer, and asked for a written response by January 12, 2024. EchoStar closed the acquisition four days later, on December 31.
On January 4, 2024, EchoStar filed a mixed shelf registration statement. BHG wrote the same day to move the response deadline up to January 8, and on January 9 it wrote again to say that the deadline had passed without a response. On January 10, EchoStar disclosed that it had moved assets out of DISH into a new EchoStar subsidiary. Two days later, EchoStar filed the prospectus for its offer to exchange DISH notes. That prospectus warned that a court could find the transfers fraudulent, and that holders might then receive no repayment on the new notes.
BHG published its first public letter to EchoStar’s board on January 22, 2024. The fifteen-page letter set out the impairment analysis, the conflict of interest, and BHG’s view that the January transfers were fraudulent conveyances. BHG copied the SEC, the SEC’s Office of the Whistleblower, and the PCAOB, as it did with every public letter after it. On February 5, BHG wrote about EchoStar’s silence since that letter, about the S&P recovery ratings on DISH’s secured debt, and about KPMG’s position as auditor to both companies. On February 15, BHG wrote about EchoStar’s termination three days earlier of its remaining debt exchange offers, which BHG treated as a further triggering event. On February 22, BHG wrote about the roughly $995 million of 2.375% notes due March 15, 2024. In BHG’s view, repaying those notes in full would favor their holders over creditors of equal rank.
On March 11, 2024, BHG responded to EchoStar’s first combined Form 10-K. In BHG’s view, that Form 10-K still carried nearly all of the more than $15 billion difference. BHG wrote the same day to Senators Elizabeth Warren and Sheldon Whitehouse of the Senate Finance Committee, with copies to every member of the committee, and asked the committee to press the SEC to act. To BHG’s knowledge, EchoStar did not respond publicly to any of the letters.
The Outcome
EchoStar’s Form 10-K for 2023, filed on February 29, 2024, disclosed substantial doubt about the company’s ability to continue as a going concern. On its earnings call on March 1, 2024, management said the company had impaired goodwill across all of its segments because its market capitalization had been depressed for a prolonged period. BHG put those charges at about $2 billion, far short of the overstatement it had identified.
On November 6, 2025, EchoStar reported a one-time, non-cash impairment charge of $16.48 billion. The company attributed the charge to its decision to abandon and decommission portions of its 5G network, after agreeing that quarter to sell spectrum to AT&T for $22.65 billion and to SpaceX for $19 billion. The amount is close to the minimum overstatement of $15 billion that BHG estimated in 2024, although EchoStar did not attribute the charge to the conditions BHG had identified.
Chronology
Engagement conducted by The Buxton Helmsley Group, Inc..
- December 27, 2023First letter, to the board of DISH Network Corporation.
- January 4 and 9, 2024Two private letters to the board of EchoStar Corporation following the combination.
- January 22 – March 11, 2024Five public letters to the board setting out the view that reported equity was overstated by approximately $15 billion.
- March 11, 2024Public letter to the U.S. Senate Committee on Finance.
- November 6, 2025EchoStar reports a non-cash impairment charge of $16.48 billion for the third quarter, which it attributes to its spectrum sales and the decommissioning of parts of its 5G network.
Dates are from the firm’s records and the companies’ public filings. Events are listed in the order they occurred; the order is not a claim that one caused another.
Relevant Disclosure
The investor-engagement campaign described above was conducted by The Buxton Helmsley Group, Inc. (“BHG”), which was previously authorized to use the “Buxton Helmsley” trademark. Alexander E. Parker, the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Buxton Helmsley, Inc., indirectly owns and controls BHG and is a director of BHG. Neither BHG nor Buxton Helmsley, Inc. holds an ownership interest in the other. As disclosed in BHG’s public letters, BHG and/or its affiliates held a short interest in securities of EchoStar Corporation and DISH Network Corporation when those letters were issued. As of November 19, 2026, none of Buxton Helmsley, Inc., its affiliates, BHG, or Mr. Parker holds a position in securities of EchoStar Corporation. The analysis and opinions described above are those of BHG as of the dates of its letters.